Uncut (p.104) - 3 stars out of 5 - "[The album] has vaulting choruses and crashing crescendos, but is intimate too..."
Alternative Press (p.122) - 5 out of 5 - "The songs have gotten tighter...and the playing smarter, as the band refuse to narrow their vision, reaching for nothing less than greatness."
Personnel: William Seidel (vocals, acoustic guitar, electric guitar, autoharp, string synthesizer, hand claps); Justin Klug (guitar, background vocals); Ryan Weber (electric guitar, lap steel guitar, mandolin, oud, kazoo, piano, synthesizer, vibraphone, snare drum, glass, hand claps, percussion); Eric Holliday (electric guitar, banjo, claves, background vocals); Wkenneth Subert (electric guitar, pan flute, kazoo, hand claps); Dan Fischer (clarinet, cornet); Aaron Vold (trombone, drums, percussion, background vocals); Nicholas Christen Santorn (Fender Rhodes piano, organ, synthesizer, Moog synthesizer, tambourine, percussion); Leslie Cottrill (hand claps, background vocals); Mary Dibiasco, Andy Menchol (hand claps); Renee Patt, Rebecca Schoeneckey (background vocals).
Audio Mixers: Ryan Weber ; Kristian Riley.
Unknown Contributor Role: William Seidel.